moving away from a paper trail
October 23, 2007 by marshc
Moving… I am an ‘Army Brat’, and as such, was moved many times in my life, but this move is different; 16 years is the longest time in one place. And that time has flown by.
Part of a move of this sort is the activity of sifting through my ‘paper chase’; tangible evidence of people, places, memories; evidence that can be held in the hand. A velvet flower, a letter from my mother, a photograph ; held, looked at, then either discarded or put into the ’save’ box. Save for…..what? to look over and sift through again, perhaps. This is my ‘paper trail’, and it is very hard to let go of what to anyone else would be useful in starting a fire in the wood stove.
I have been thinking about this and wondering about the students I work with, some of whom have also experienced a lot of ‘moving house’ in their lives. Most of these children are very much at home with computers, the internet, and the technology we are using now in our middle school. Will people always have a ‘paper trail’, or is this something peculiar to my age and generation? Writings, emails, photographs and more are stored on discs…the whole world is on disc. And these evidences of lives can be printed, sure. But will these printouts of the future lives of my students embody the same kind of sentiment/memories that I feel when gathering, sorting, saving, and sometimes discarding the tangible evidences of my life?
Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)
I think the richness of life comes from the interactions we have with others and with our experiences. To narrow those interactions by restricting them to only one form of memory, whether, digital, cognitive, or on paper would surely narrow the scope of ones life. I am always seeking a balance among the ways in which I experience the world and I hope that I have done well. As for our students, I would ask how do we, as individuals, teams, and institutions model this? Are we seeking balance? Do we offer students the opportunities to find other ways in which they can return to the experiences of their lives?
You, as a member of your team, provide students with lots of experiences, tangible and intangible. A work that they are proud of will be saved as a hard copy. Think of all the things you provide for them as part of a middle school faculty: hiking field trips, visits to historical sites, conversations — these may not be tangible memories, but they certainly are ones that enhance their living experiences. There’s a balance between tangible and intangible, being aware of that need proves that your students will not be left out of the tangible ones!
Your ponderings are put so prettily, and you touch on such a crucial component of generational divides in the uses of technology. I think the value of the “paper trail”, of any of the mementos we hold on to and carry with us, is that we have invested our emotional memories into the visual cues of the objects. Although “real-world” objects may hold certain sensory information not recordable in a digital form (the faded scent of perfume, the soft touch of velvet), digital forms may store other forms (photos set to a soundtrack, for example). The key, I think, is that we hold on to things that remind us of the feelings we had at a certain time. As the common tools of everyday experience change (email vs letters, etc), so will the common cues for our memories. What feels tangible may even change as people’s habits of interactions change.
The richness, as Rick says, comes from the interactions we have with others and, I would suggest, ourselves. As such, the forms with which we choose to preserve our memories will always come down to that with which we are most comfortable, most familiar.
As educators, it is certainly a worthy goal to share with our students multiple formats, and opportunities, to create their own cues for recording what they value in their lives.